Celestino's NY Pizza storefront

Our Story

Born in New York. Built in Chico.

Since April 1, 1997, we've been making the real thing — thin crust, fresh ingredients, and the kind of pizza that makes you close your eyes on the first bite.

How It Started

Started on April Fool's Day. No joke.

Celestino's Pizza opened its doors on April 1, 1997 — April Fool's Day. The timing was a coincidence, but the mission was dead serious: bring authentic New York thin-crust pizza to Chico, California.

The plan was simple. Use real ingredients. Hand-stretch every dough. Keep the recipes honest. They figured if they made the real thing, people would come. They were right.

Nearly three decades later, the downtown Chico location is still owned and operated by the original owners. Same recipes. Same standards. Same love for the craft.

Pizza chef hand-stretching dough

1997

Est. Chico, CA

"They had a simple plan: offer authentic New York thin-crust pizza and they will come."

— Celestino's, April 1, 1997

What Makes Us Different

Hand-Stretched Every Time

No shortcuts. Every crust is hand-stretched to order, giving you that signature thin, crispy-yet-chewy New York bite.

Real Ingredients Only

San Marzano tomatoes, whole-milk mozzarella, fresh basil. We source quality ingredients because the pizza deserves it.

Original Owners, Original Recipes

The same family has run this place since day one. The recipes haven't changed because they don't need to.

Part of the Chico Community

We've fed Chico for nearly 30 years — families, students, late-night crews. This city is home, and we're grateful for every slice shared.

Celestino's dining roomFresh pizza ingredients

The Craft

New York pizza is a technique, not just a recipe.

The thin crust that folds without cracking. The sauce that doesn't overpower. The cheese that pulls just right. It takes practice, patience, and a refusal to cut corners. We've been perfecting it since 1997.

27+

Years in business

Countless

Pies made

Still here

Original owners

27 years of Chico pizza history — worth sharing.

Share this pageX

Come See for Yourself

The best way to understand what we're about is to pull up a chair and order a pie.