Chico's Favorite Since 1997
Authentic New York Pizza. Right Here in Chico.
Thin crust. Real ingredients. Original owners. We've been slinging NY-style pies since April 1, 1997 — and we're not stopping.
Our History
Started on April Fool's Day. No joke.
Celestino's Pizza opened for Business on April Fool's Day, April 1, 1997. They had a simple plan: Offer Authentic New York thin-crust Pizza and they will come!
The Chico-Downtown store is still owned & operated by the original owners!
"They had a simple plan."
Visit Us
101 Salem St, Chico, CA
Hours
- Mon – Fri10:30 am – 8:30 pm
- Saturday11:00 am – 8:30 pm
- Sunday4:00 pm – 8:30 pm
What People Are Saying
Chico's Been Talking Since '97
5.0 · Loved by Chico
"Best pizza in Chico, hands down. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy — exactly how New York pizza should be. We've been coming here for years and it never disappoints."
Sarah M.
Regular since 2004
"I grew up in New York and was skeptical, but Celestino's is the real deal. The sauce, the cheese, the fold — it's all there. This place is a gem."
Mike T.
New York transplant
"Our family orders from here every Friday night. The garlic knots alone are worth the trip. Original owners still running it — you can taste the care in every bite."
The Rodriguez Family
Friday night regulars
"I've tried every pizza place in Chico. Nothing comes close. The NY slice is massive, foldable, and absolutely delicious. 27 years in business for a reason."
Jason K.
Chico local
"Took my out-of-town friends here and they couldn't believe how good it was. Authentic thin crust, generous toppings, and the staff is always friendly. A Chico institution."
Priya L.
CSU Chico alum
Get in Touch
Contact Us
Have a question or special request? We'd love to hear from you.